What do clients really want from their CPA? In the first of four articles unpacking CalCPA's Leadership Forum, leaders explore the gap between the value firms think they deliver and what clients say they need—and how trust, AI and new pricing models can help close it.
There’s a shift in what clients expect from their CPA firms. While technical skills are still needed, clients are seeking more than the work firms have traditionally delivered. They want help making decisions.
How firms can best meet these new expectations was one of four topics discussed during CalCPA’s Leadership Forum, which brought together members and thought leaders from across the profession to examine emerging challenges, explore opportunities and help shape the profession’s direction.
The “Adequate” Problem
Panelists Dean Quiambao, Chief Relationship Builder at Armanino, and Puja Dalmia-Ramasubban, a senior tax & accounting adviser, shared some examples of what this client expectation shift looks like: A private equity CFO who said he wasn’t concerned about K-1s, but wanted to understand the impact of writing off a $150 million investment. Or the CEO who admitted he spends a lot of time “bouncing ideas around my own head.”
Clients want someone who can help them think through scenarios and talk over big decisions.
Tax returns, K-1s and audits are still important, but many clients now see them as expected services—work that technology can increasingly handle. “Things that we took a lot of pride in before, that’s all going to be done,” Quiambao said.
That creates a disconnect. Firms want to be every client’s “first call,” but clients often describe their relationship with their CPA as merely “adequate.” Even good clients may sum up the value as, “They save me money on taxes,” which is a much narrower relationship than many firms hope to build.
Why Value Conversations Stall
The leaders didn’t shy away from what gets in the way of delivering these new expectations. Heavy workloads leave little time for proactive conversations, and clients can feel overlooked when their CPA is busy. Clients don’t always spell out what they need and accountants don’t always ask. Sometimes it feels easier to absorb the extra work than to have an uncomfortable conversation about fees or expectations.
Firms can also fall into the habit of explaining their value before finding out what matters most to the client.
Putting numbers to the importance of this issue, recent research showed that 76 percent of buyers would have rehired their provider five years ago, compared with 50 percent today—and that figure is projected to fall to 33 percent in three years. The dropoff isn’t necessarily because of bad service. It’s options. Clients have more of them these days, making it easier for new providers to enter the market, and newer buyers may feel less loyalty to longstanding relationships.
A New Promise, an Old Model
Adding to this challenge is the fact that most firms are being asked to deliver a new kind of value while relying on business models built around the old one.
For years, the profession worked in—and taught clients to think in—hours. AI is making that harder to defend and panelists said fees could come under pressure before firms see the benefits of new pricing approaches. “If we’re talking about cost, it’s wrong,” Quiambao said. “We need to talk about value.”
Flat-fee and subscription pricing can help firms move away from justifying every hour, but changing the price alone won’t do it. Compensation, staffing, utilization targets and performance reviews also need to reward results, not simply activity. As one participant asked, how does the profession “unsend” the message that value equals time?
AI is the First Mile, Not the Last
Panelists said that simply using widely available AI tools won’t set a firm apart for long. The bigger opportunity is to apply AI to a firm’s expertise and the “gold mine” of client data it already has. The AI accounting software market is projected to reach $150 billion globally within six to seven years, compared with a U.S. accounting services market of $100 billion to $120 billion today.
The profession is facing a major shift, whether firms feel ready or not.
Even with better technology, clients still want human judgment. Quiambao once built an AI agent that mimicked him, and clients asked, “Is this really you?” His takeaway was simple: automate the tasks you don’t want to do, then use the time you gain to be more present with clients. People still want a trusted person in their corner. AI should give firms more time to be that person.
Trust Opens the Door
Trust is a major reason clients stay with their CPAs. One business owner reportedly passed up millions in tax savings rather than leave a CPA he’d worked with for 30 years. A firm’s name may get it in the door, but the client’s experience with the people doing the work is what builds the relationship.
Leaders said CPAs earn a place in strategic conversations by being curious, admitting when they don’t have an immediate answer and offering to work through it with the client. They can also spot patterns across clients and use benchmarking and analysis to show where they add value. As one leader put it, “Nobody cares about the new tax law. They only care what it means to them.”
Clients are no longer just paying for deliverables. They want answers, help making better decisions and confidence about what comes next.
In Part 2, we turn from clients to the people who serve them, exploring how AI, retirements and a pandemic-shaped generation of professionals are reshaping the talent model of CPA firms.


